Options Press

Incorrect Date Costs Broker Nearly $23M in Liabilities


A trading regulator found discount brokerage Interactive Brokers liable for posting an incorrect date and awarded a New Jersey man a record $2.4 million in damages.

NYPost

But that’s only a fraction of the $22.7 million he lost on a botched trade because of the bad information.

The pyrrhic victory for day trader Frank M. Cerisano Jr. by the Financial Industry Regulation Authority is three times the next-largest award against IB, according to Cerisano’s lawyer, Sam Lieberman of Sadis & Goldberg.

Cerisano plies his trade in the backwaters of day trading — derivatives and the esoteric future contracts, where millions can be bet with little upfront.

This special breed of people manage to get to sleep at night with huge positions hanging fire as Asian markets can take out a wager in a flicker of the screen.

The last thing a futures trader needs is to have his trading platform also go against him. This is what Cerisano and his lawyer alleged.

In June 2013, Cerisano was taking a huge position in VIX Futures that climbed as high as $200 million with leverage.

The Chicago Board Options Exchange’s Volatility Index (VIX) was on the move then. In the six weeks prior to the position, the VIX spiked nearly 42 percent on central banks sending markets mixed messages of future easing.

If the trade had been executed on the expiration date Cerisano found on IB’s website, he would have netted roughly $2.5 million in profit.

But IB maintained the expiration date was the following day, which created a huge loss as the VIX moved dramatically away from Cerisano’s position.

The botched futures trade appears to be human back-office error at IB, which used the correct expiration date internally, but then inexplicably displayed it as a day earlier on its website, which Cerisano used to price his gains.

Interactive was not accused of fraud. But Cerisano certainly felt misled.

At the IB internal expiration date, the broker dealer settled the trade and took $25.3 million out of Cerisano’s account, according to his lawyer.

Cerisano is said to be one of Interactive’s largest derivative traders.

When Cerisano figured out what actually happened, he lodged his complaint. Instead of sympathy and recompense, he got the cold shoulder, according to his attorney. “My client has had to pay tens of millions of dollars in commission to Interactive Brokers over the years, so he was surprised that that was the approach, even when they were caught red-handed,” Lieberman told The Post.

Some trading experts were surprised at how the events played out.

“Someone sophisticated enough to manage a $100 million VIX Futures portfolio also has the resources to verify something as simple as the expiration date of a product, particularly if that expiration poses significant risk to their portfolio,” said Mark Longo, a former trader at the Chicago Board Options Exchange and CEO of industry news outlet The Options Insider.

Still, it may not have been that simple. The back office at Interactive Brokers may have been thrown into confusion, too, Lieberman said. The industry had changed the expiration date of the relatively new VIX Futures on several occasions since 2011.

Others say the fiasco illustrated some disturbing aspects of modern electronic trading. “Many of the back-office systems are so antiquated in the options and futures markets,” said Chris Nagy, a market structure expert and CEO at the KOR Group. “Humans do make mistakes, and computers don’t know enough to understand those mistakes.”

Lieberman said there are a lot of other investors who potentially incurred losses on VIX Futures through Interactive. “They just haven’t looked at their account statement to see the difference,” he added.

Interactive Brokers, based in Greenwich, Conn., had no comment for this story.

It’s not the first time Interactive has run into trouble with its online system and the regulators.

Last month, for example, a reported $667,000 was awarded by a separate Finra arbitration panel in another Interactive case. The discount broker was ordered to pay that amount to a hedge fund that suffered losses when Interactive’s system was found to have malfunctioned.



The Options News RundownAudio

Your source for the most important news and information from the world of options.

The Options Insider Radio NetworkAudio

All of our radio programs in one convenient place.

Options Insider RadioAudio

The original options podcast. Features interviews with leading options figures.

The Option BlockAudio

This high-octane program features education, analysis, strategies and unusual activity.

Volatility ViewsAudio

The premier radio program for volatility traders.

The Long And Short Of Futures OptionsAudio

Your source for futures options information.

The Advisor's OptionAudio

Arming advisors with the info necessary to manage risk.

Options Boot CampAudio

Get into peak options trading shape.

Options Insider Special EventsAudio

Compelling panel & special event recordings from the options world.

OIC's Wide World of OptionsAudio

A dynamic mix of current events, investor resources, & strategy insights.

Trading Tech TalkAudio

We break down all the amazing technology that takes your trades from the click of a mouse to the clearinghouse.

Options Playbook RadioAudio

Break down cutting-edge options strategies and learn how to incorporate them into your portfolio

Options OdditiesAudio

We track all the unusual options trading activity on Options Oddities.

This Week in Futures OptionsAudio

The program designed to help active futures options traders stay on top of this ever-changing marketplace. 

The Business ShowAudio

If you like business, if you like humor, if you like stock symbols, this is the podcast for you.
x

The Options Insider Radio Network

The Options News Rundown

Your source for the most important news and information from the world of options.

The Options News Rundown

The Options Insider Radio Network

All of our radio programs in one convenient place.

The Options Insider Radio Network

Options Insider Radio

The original options podcast. Features interviews with leading options figures.

Options Insider Radio

The Option Block

This high-octane program features education, analysis, strategies and unusual activity.

The Option Block

Volatility Views

The premier radio program for volatility traders.

Volatility Views

The Long And Short Of Futures Options

Your source for futures options information.

The Long And Short Of Futures Options

The Advisor's Option

Arming advisors with the info necessary to manage risk.

The Advisor's Option

Options Boot Camp

Get into peak options trading shape.

Options Boot Camp

Options Insider Special Events

Compelling panel & special event recordings from the options world.

Options Insider Special Events

OIC's Wide World of Options

A dynamic mix of current events, investor resources, & strategy insights.

OIC's Wide World of Options

Trading Tech Talk

We break down all the amazing technology that takes your trades from the click of a mouse to the clearinghouse.

Trading Tech Talk

Options Playbook Radio

Break down cutting-edge options strategies and learn how to incorporate them into your portfolio

Options Playbook Radio

Options Oddities

We track all the unusual options trading activity on Options Oddities.

Options Oddities

This Week in Futures Options

The program designed to help active futures options traders stay on top of this ever-changing marketplace. 

This Week in Futures Options

The Business Show

If you like business, if you like humor, if you like stock symbols, this is the podcast for you.

The Business Show

Options News Rundown: Monday, December 10, 2018

Options news you can use for Monday, December 10, 2018

Options News Rundown: Monday, December 10, 2018